Third Party vs Comprehensive Insurance

When looking for insurance, you'll see different terms flying around. We're explaining the difference between Third party, fire & theft and Comprehensive cover.

Megan Roberts (Marketing Executive)

By Megan Roberts

Updated on Dec 4th, 2020

Looking at getting insurance for the first time is scary and confusing, and there are probably many terms flying around that you’ve never heard of, or at least, have no clue what they mean – and comprehensive, third party, third party fire and theft, all fall into the land of ‘what are you talking about’ for first time drivers. To make it clearer, and so you know which is best for you, we’re outlining what they are and what you can expect choosing one or the others.

The different types of insurance cover

Generally, insurers will give you the option between 3 different types of cover. They are:

  • Third party
  • Third party, fire and theft (TPFT)
  • Comprehensive

It’s worth noting that many insurance companies no longer offer Third party only cover, and TPFT is the lowest level of cover they will go to. Because of that, we’ll be looking at the pros and cons of TPFT and Comprehensive cover in this blog, to help you when it comes to making the decision.

Third party, fire and theft

TPFT is the minimum amount of cover many insurers will provide you with (unless you’re able to get Third party only cover), and you need this to legally drive in the UK. If you get into an accident, your insurance will cover losses to any third party vehicles or property, but any damage to your own car will not be covered and you have to stump up the costs to fix. If your car is involved in an accident with fire or it is stolen, you will also be covered.

Comprehensive cover

Also known as fully comprehensive, this insurance cover is one of the higher levels of cover you can get on your car, and includes all of the features of TPFT as well as cover for paying out for damage on your own car in the case of a claim, even if you’re at fault.

Is comprehensive cover more expensive?

You’d be forgiven for thinking that comprehensive insurance is more expensive than TPFT, however, this is not always the case. Insurers may put the price lower on a comprehensive policy, as you’ll be deemed more responsible for choosing the higher level of cover. It is worth always checking the prices of the different cover options available, as more protection may be cheaper than you think.

If comprehensive cover is more expensive, it’s still worth considering. Would you be able to afford to replace or repair your own car in the event of an accident? If the answer is no – it may be wise to part with a bit of extra money on your insurance to cover you should you need it!

Other ways to save on car insurance

Whilst your level of cover can determine the price you pay for your insurance, there are many more factors that will go into the price you pay, and of course, a big one on this is to get a black box insurance policy – one of the best ways to keep insurance costs low for young drivers. What’s even better is with Marmalade, all insurance policies are of comprehensive cover as standard!

Get the car of your dreams

Get a brand new car and we’ll give you up to £1300 towards your first year’s insurance!* With deposits from just £500, you could be driving away in your new car before you know it!
Check out our range of cars perfect for young drivers and see which one suits you!
Megan Roberts (Marketing Executive)

By Megan Roberts

Hi, I'm Megan - I have recently graduated from university and I'm a marketing executive at Marmalade! I am a new driver myself and would love to share my tips, tricks and experiences with you :)

Related Blogs

Buying a car vs borrowing a car

After passing your test, it's difficult to know what to do next. We're weighing up the options between buying and borrowing a car.

In-car tech: Built in Sat Navs

We recently ran a survey to see how important in-car tech was to drivers. Find out who wants a built-in sat-nav the most, and which is the best option.

win a car

Win a Brand New Car!

Sign up to our newsletter for a chance to win a brand new car!

friends happy on phones

Visit the Driver Hub

Check out the latest stories and blogs from young drivers

smiling teen girl

Become a Marmalade blogger!

Get involved, share your stories and earn shopping vouchers

Trustpilot logo
Customer Service Excellence Awards
BIBA scheme provider logo
First car award 2019 winner logo